Darkly Speaking

20. MURDERED: Jonelle Matthews — The Cold Case Behind the Girl on the Milk Carton

41:05

Five days before Christmas in 1984, 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews returned to her home in Greely Colorado after a school concert and vanished without a trace.

No forced entry. No struggle. Just footprints in the snow behind the Matthews home.

Her disappearance quickly gained national attention, becoming one of the first cases featured in the milk carton campaign. And for nearly four decades,…